The Shelves Paradox

Why do I have more books than can fit on my shelves?  If I want to locate Fahrenheit 451, (which surely I must own), after I look through the main shelves in our library and living room, I also have to check the shelf in my upstairs office, the shelves in my son’s and daughter’s rooms, another bookshelf and three more boxes in the attic, and one box in the basement.  Then I check my Kindle, too.

This is not a system.  This is a happy meandering through my collection or a bothersome, fruitless task, depending on how urgently I want the book and whether I find it.  Include the toss-up of whether I’ll still remember what I’m looking for by the time I find everything else, and it’s quite the party here.

We have a very nice public library in our town that accepts books for its book sales.  Knowing this, I occasionally cull books from my shelves and drop them in a box in my closet until it gets too full, and then I move the books in shopping bags to my garage to let them attract leaves for a few weeks before I haul them off.

It tends to be raining each time I take books to the library.  Don’t ask me why.  Recall that bags disintegrate when wet.  I try to scamper with my arms loaded, in a great hurry because my next errand invariably involves meeting someone at the airport or getting to the dump before it closes. It’s a soggy, immodest, pathetic business, especially when I end up pulling certain choice titles out of my donation pile because I can’t bear, after all, to let them go.

Naturally, I have started dreaming of more shelves, but I don’t know where to put them.  I also yearn paradoxically for simplicity and self-restraint, as it would please me to have only my very favorite books ready to hand.  I want more books, but I also want fewer books.  I don’t see a solution, frankly.  It is one of the great, unsolvable problems of our time.

5 Responses to The Shelves Paradox

  • Ahhhhh…..a common problem in my house too. Since I have moved twice in the past year, I am extra aware of the extensive collection that John and I have amassed. My solution has been to donate what’s still good to the library (for their semi-annual sale, and as a tax deduction) and drop the really tired ones at the swap shop at the dump. Most importantly, I have culled out a selection which I’ve taken to our lake house – now the whole extended family, including the children, are reading them! Maybe some of your favorites could take a one-way trip to the mid-west with you this summer….then you’ll be able to rediscover them and be delighted for years to come.

  • Davetta ~ A move might force me to deal with the books properly, I suppose. I prefer the idea of acquiring a lake house to accommodate the overflow. I’m glad to know your favorites are making the rounds because truly that’s the best.
    May you stay put for a while now.
    All best,

  • i love/hate this problem! the worst is, i tell myself i’ll cut down by only keeping or buying my favorite books… but they’re all my favorites! conundrum!

  • Too true, for many of us, I’m afraid.

  • alas ~ “They’re all my favorites!” How very true. Terrible, isn’t it?
    Heidi ~ I know. We should form a club. Or a joint library or something. I bet Ben Franklin had our same problem when he started the first lending library.
    All best,

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Caragh's Latest Favorite Reads

The Guernsey Literary and Potato Peel Pie Society
Every Day
The Dog Stars
The Reinvention of Edison Thomas
The Sweetness at the Bottom of the Pie
The Fault in Our Stars
Two of a Kind
Until It Hurts to Stop

Caragh's books »
Book Trailer for Promised