#1 You May Not Read A Book You Dislike

He'll read if he can pick his own book and have time for it in class.

I instituted Independent Reading in all of my high school English classes for a half hour every Friday.  The first semester, many of my students didn’t get it.  They thought it was time to sleep, pass notes, text, doodle on the desks, do homework, do their hair, or meet in the library to socialize.  My fellow teachers informed me they didn’t have such time to spare in their classrooms, so I understood they were suspicious of my new-teacher methods.  I looked lazy.  I was gently requested to produce research to back up that independent reading increased test scores, and when I started looking, I became even more convinced that my gut instinct was dead on: kids who read more score better, and the surest way to get teens to read more is to let them choose what they’re reading.  Supporting reading with actual time in the classroom was valid pedagogy.

So why wasn’t it working in my classroom?

My students were accustomed to a climate of accountability rather than independence, for one thing, but I thought I had that covered.  I had Lit Letter and Book Talk assignments spaced throughout the semester, weekly charts for them to record their total hours read, and another chart for them to keep track of and rate the books they’d read and abandoned. I’d studied my Nancy Atwell.  I discovered my students responded well to clear expectations, so I created an assessment for in-class reading on Fridays (see below).  Altogether, it still felt like an unsuccessful, task-minded game I was losing.

Students' Favorite Books

I persevered.  It makes sense that as I improved with all my teaching, I also became better at running Independent Reading.  With better classroom management, I became quicker at redirecting off-task behavior, as in noticing a student as soon as she wasn’t reading and pointing politely to my own book. I also built up my in-class library, propping popular books on whiteboard trays, shelves and windowsills.  I made a point of talking about Independent Reading on the first day of class, and at Open House night when parents came.  I went to the school library with my students during the first week of the semester to let them roam and help them pick out books.  We created lists of “If you like this book, try this one,” and we generated book wish lists from browsing Amazon.  I invited the school librarian to read to my students and talk up the newest popular books.  I invited the public library librarian to come and she issued library cards to my students.  I reserved the big blue chairs in the library for us to visit as an entire class occasionally.   One of my teacher friends started independent reading in her class, and then another teacher started, too.  It became a stealth race to see who would sign up to reserve the big blue chairs first.

Honestly, it took a few semesters for independent reading to take off, but then it really did.  It became the  norm in other English classes, too, so students were used to the routine year after year.  On Fridays, my students came to class prepared with books.  We would sit in utter silence for 30 minutes, companionably reading together, all 29 of us.  If I tried to short-change the half hour for some other urgent teaching business or an all-school assembly, my students openly protested.  We sometimes voted to extend reading another 10 minutes.  The related assignments, like Lit Letters and Book Talks, when each student presented a recent read in a 2-3 minute speech at the podium, became pertinent and inspiring.  My students swapped books with each other, squealed about books together, and spontaneously started reading whenever they ended any other learning activity early because that’s what they wanted to do.  In short, it worked.

I didn’t need any test scores to tell me: my students were readers.


In-Class Reading Assessment

6 Responses to #1 You May Not Read A Book You Dislike

  • that’s so awesome! i wish my english teacher did that…

  • I require my students to read a novel and a children’s book in my social studies classes and I even read aloud to them for about 10 minutes a day. It is amazing that some teachers and administrators didn’t get that this was beneficial to the students. Now most everyone supports my reading practice in the classroom but it was a huge struggle when I started doing it. Reading definitely matters.

  • Great post – I appreciate you sharing the details of how it takes time for things like this to work in a school, rather than being instantly successful. 🙂

  • Laura ~ I bet your students love the reading aloud. It makes it a community and bonding event then, building on the power of story. Cool!
    Claire ~ It is true that new things, even good things, take time to work. When teachers have a chance to try their own ideas and keep tweaking, they can do amazing things.
    All best,

  • Great post. I really enjoyed it. It is a different way of teaching and you are clearly working your way through that; it’s useful for others in a similar situation to read your account.

    Are you also explicitly teaching and modelling comprehension? Do students keep track of their thinking? Are you conferring with them as readers? (So it’s not just “Silent Reading”?).

  • Tom ~
    I did tons of comprehension modeling and activities with other reading in my class, so the students’ skills were always developing through more typical instruction, but the independent reading allowed them to truly engage with text at their own pace, without interruption, for their own pleasure. Their “thinking” about their independent reading choices was evident in their Lit Letters, Book Talks, and casual conversations. You make me think about doing a post on my favorite comprehension activities.
    I also did an experiment with my low-achieving ninth grade students where we read twenty minutes daily for a month, again with books of their own choice. Many of them had never finished an entire book before. At the end of the month, the students voted to do it for another month. What was really striking was their speed. Many had been reading so slowly they could hardly keep the idea of an entire sentence forming in their minds from the beginning of the sentence to the end. Once the words could flow, the students could understand, so their comprehension improved.
    All best,

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.

Caragh's Latest Favorite Reads

The Guernsey Literary and Potato Peel Pie Society
Every Day
The Dog Stars
The Reinvention of Edison Thomas
The Sweetness at the Bottom of the Pie
The Fault in Our Stars
Two of a Kind
Until It Hurts to Stop

Caragh's books »
Book Trailer for Promised